Here’s a detailed guide on what the HLR process for a VA disability claim involves, how to initiate it, and tips for navigating it effectively.
When veterans receive a VA disability claim decision that doesn’t seem correct, they can request a Higher-Level Review (HLR) to have their claim re-evaluated. The HLR process offers an opportunity for veterans to receive a second look at their claim by a senior VA adjudicator, without submitting new evidence.
Understanding the HLR Process for VA Disability Claims
So, what is the HLR process for a VA disability claim? The Higher-Level Review (HLR) process is one of the three primary appeals options under the Appeals Modernization Act of 2017. It enables veterans to request that their initial disability claim decision be re-evaluated by a senior reviewer who was not involved in the original decision. The HLR reviewer focuses on identifying errors in the initial decision or potential misinterpretations of the evidence already on file, without introducing any new evidence.
This process is valuable for veterans who feel that their claim decision was affected by a clear error in the application of the law or by an overlooked piece of evidence. Knowing what the HLR process for a VA disability claim entails can help veterans determine if it’s the right choice for their case.
AI Powered Chatbot for VA Disability Claims
Learn more about the VA Disability process and get help with our VA Disability Claim Chatbot programmed and trained by AI
Eligibility for the HLR Process
Any veteran who has received an initial VA disability claim decision and disagrees with the outcome can request an HLR. However, the request for HLR must be filed within one year of the original decision date.
The HLR process is ideal if:
- You believe there was a clear error in how the VA applied the law.
- You think the original decision overlooked or misinterpreted existing evidence.
- You want a faster review option and are not planning to add new evidence.
If new evidence has become available that would strengthen your case, a Supplemental Claim might be a more suitable option than HLR.
Steps in the HLR Process for a VA Disability Claim
To fully understand what the HLR process for a VA disability claim entails, let’s break down the necessary steps for requesting an HLR:
Step 1: Complete VA Form 20-0996
Start by completing VA Form 20-0996, “Decision Review Request: Higher-Level Review.” This form allows you to specify the areas of the initial decision you believe were in error, focusing the HLR reviewer’s attention on these points.
- Tip: Be as detailed as possible in identifying specific errors in the original decision. Mention any legal misapplications or overlooked evidence that you believe impacted the initial decision.
Step 2: Consider Requesting an Informal Conference
On the form, you’ll have the option to request an informal conference with the HLR reviewer. This informal conference is a phone call between you (or your representative) and the reviewer to discuss the specific errors you’ve identified. While new evidence cannot be introduced, an informal conference gives you a chance to provide verbal clarification and ensure the reviewer understands the errors in the initial decision.
- Note: Although an informal conference may slightly extend the review time, it can be useful for emphasizing your points and strengthening your case.
Step 3: Submit the Form
Once the form is completed, you can submit it in a few ways:
- Online: Submit through the VA’s eBenefits or VA.gov portal.
- Mail: Send the completed form to the VA office that issued the original decision.
- In Person: Deliver the form to your local VA Regional Office.
Step 4: Await the HLR Decision
After submission, the VA assigns your claim to a senior reviewer. This reviewer will reassess the claim based on the evidence in the record and identify any potential errors or misinterpretations. Generally, HLR decisions are processed within 4-5 months, though times may vary depending on regional office workloads.
What the HLR Reviewer Looks for in a VA Disability Claim
In understanding what the HLR process for a VA disability claim includes, it’s important to know what the reviewer focuses on. During HLR, the reviewer will evaluate the claim to:
- Identify Existing Evidence Errors: The review is limited to the original evidence submitted, with a focus on any overlooked or misinterpreted elements.
- Correct Legal Application: The reviewer will ensure that laws and regulations were correctly applied in the initial decision.
- Improve Decision Accuracy: The HLR process aims to provide a fresh and thorough review to determine if an accurate decision was made based on the record.
Important Note: The HLR process does not allow veterans to add any new evidence, so if you have new documentation or recent medical evidence, consider submitting a Supplemental Claim instead.
Advantages of the HLR Process for a VA Disability Claim
Choosing the HLR process has specific advantages for veterans seeking a swift and accurate re-evaluation of their claim:
- Faster Resolution: HLR is generally faster than other appeals processes, as it doesn’t require new evidence or re-evaluation of additional documentation.
- More Experienced Review: The HLR is conducted by a senior reviewer, ensuring a higher level of expertise in evaluating potential errors in the original decision.
- Error Correction Without New Evidence: For cases where the issue lies in the initial assessment rather than in a lack of evidence, HLR is a focused, streamlined option.
The specific benefits can help veterans decide what the HLR process for a VA disability claim may offer compared to other appeals options.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Requesting HLR
When navigating what the HLR process for a VA disability claim involves, it’s essential to avoid common errors to improve your chances of a favorable outcome.
Mistake 1: Overlooking Specific Errors
Be precise when describing the errors in your initial decision. Avoid vague statements, and instead, point to specific sections or evidence that was overlooked or misinterpreted.
Mistake 2: Requesting HLR with New Evidence Available
Since HLR does not allow new evidence, requesting it without having a solid original record could weaken your case. If you have new evidence, consider a Supplemental Claim instead.
Mistake 3: Missing the One-Year Filing Window
HLR requests must be submitted within one year of the original decision date. Missing this deadline may require starting a new claim or choosing a different appeals path.
Mistake 4: Not Consulting a VSO or Representative
Veterans Service Officers (VSOs) and VA-accredited representatives can provide guidance, help identify errors, and strengthen your case. Consulting a representative can ensure you avoid common mistakes and increase your chances of a positive review.
What to Expect After an HLR Decision
After the HLR review, the VA will send a decision letter outlining the findings. Here’s what each possible outcome may mean:
- Decision Overturned: If errors are found, the decision may be changed in your favor, potentially increasing your disability rating or awarding benefits.
- Decision Upheld: If no errors are found, the original decision will remain in effect. At this point, you may consider further options, such as a Supplemental Claim or appealing to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals if additional evidence is available.
- Partial Decision Changes: In some cases, only part of the decision may be changed. Review the details of the decision letter carefully, as it will outline specific findings and next steps.
By understanding what the HLR process for a VA disability claim might mean in each scenario, veterans can prepare themselves for possible outcomes.
