The VA disability 5 year rule is an important concept for veterans who receive disability compensation for service-connected conditions.
This rule impacts how the VA reviews and adjusts a veteran’s disability rating after five years of continuous compensation. Understanding this rule can help veterans anticipate future changes and safeguard their benefits. In this article, we’ll explore how the VA 5 year rule works, how it applies to conditions like PTSD, and when VA disability becomes permanent.
Need Some More Help with your VA Disability?
Learn more about the VA Disability process and get help with our VA Disability Chatbot programmed and trained by AI
What is the VA Disability 5 Year Rule?
The VA disability 5 year rule means that the VA is less likely to reduce a veteran’s disability rating after the veteran has had the same rating for five years. Once a disability rating has been in effect for five years, the VA will only reduce it if they can prove that the condition has significantly improved and that this improvement is sustained over time. This rule offers some protection for veterans, ensuring their rating remains stable if there has not been a major change in their health.
VA Disability 5 Year Rule and PTSD
The VA disability 5 year rule also applies to veterans with PTSD (Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder). PTSD can be a fluctuating condition, and the VA understands that. After a veteran has received the same rating for PTSD for five years, the VA will need strong evidence to prove that the condition has improved enough to warrant a reduction. If the veteran’s symptoms remain stable or worsen, the rating will typically not be reduced.
When Does VA Disability Become Permanent?
Veterans often ask, when does VA disability become permanent? The VA five year rule is one step toward permanency, but it doesn’t automatically make a disability permanent. After five years, the VA will be less likely to reduce a rating without proof of long-term improvement. However, a veteran’s rating is not considered Permanent and Total (P&T) unless the VA explicitly assigns this status.
The VA can assign P&T status if they believe the condition will not improve over time. Once this status is granted, the veteran is no longer subject to routine re-examinations, and their benefits are locked in for life.
For more information on how the VA determines permanent disability status, check the VA’s eligibility page.
Its also important to understand how long do VA payments last as well.
VA 5 Year Rule: Protection Against Reductions
The VA 5 year rule provides protection for veterans who have had the same rating for an extended period. Once the five-year mark is reached, the VA can still review a veteran’s case, but the burden of proof is higher. The VA must show that the veteran’s condition has improved to justify reducing the rating, and the improvement must be sustained over time.
- What happens at the five-year mark?: After five years, the VA cannot reduce a rating based on a temporary improvement. If your condition improves briefly but then worsens, the VA cannot lower your rating based on that temporary change.
- Does this make my disability permanent?: While the five year rule adds some protection, it does not guarantee that your disability will become Permanent and Total. Veterans who have stable conditions that are unlikely to improve may be eligible for Permanent and Total status after five years, but this is determined by the VA on a case-by-case basis.
- Estimate Your Compensation: Use the VA Disability Calculator to calculate your potential compensation based on your rating.
For more detailed information about the five year rule and how it protects veterans from reductions, visit Sean Kendall Law’s FAQ on the VA 5 Year Rule.
VA Five Year Rule and Future Examinations
Even after the five year rule is in effect, the VA may still schedule routine exams to check the status of a veteran’s condition. However, the VA must prove sustained improvement to reduce the veteran’s rating. If your condition remains the same or worsens, your rating will stay the same or increase, but it should not be reduced.
Veterans with stable or worsening conditions can request the VA to declare their disability as Permanent and Total, which stops future re-examinations.
The VA disability 5 year rule is designed to protect veterans from unfair reductions in their disability rating. After five years, the VA must demonstrate sustained improvement in the veteran’s condition before they can reduce the rating. While this rule offers protection, it doesn’t automatically make a disability Permanent and Total. Veterans should understand how this rule impacts their benefits and work with the VA to ensure their compensation reflects their current health status.
For more details on how the VA sets effective dates for ratings and compensation, check the VA’s disability effective date guide.
